Over Fall Break I got to spend four days floating through Hells Canyon fishing the Snake River and hunting upland game birds in the canyon. On the trip we fished for Smallmouth Bass, Salmon, Rainbow Trout, and White Sturgeon. On the hunting side, we were primarily going after Chukar. At the end of the trip, I asked everyone on the trip which animal they most enjoyed pursuing. The results can be found in Table 1.
Table 1: Animal Preference Chart
Jarrett | Derek | Omar | Jacob | |
1 | Salmon | Chukar | Chukar | Sturgeon |
2 | Chukar | Bass | Trout | Bass |
3 | Sturgeon | Trout | Bass | Chukar |
4 | Trout | Sturgeon | Sturgeon | Trout |
5 | Bass | Salmon | Salmon | Salmon |
With this data, I then analyzed the results using different voting methods to see if there would be any significant differences. Chukar wins in both a plurality and majority + runoff situation. But let’s now look at the results in various ranking systems. Tables 2-4 show the result.
Table 2: Results Using the Borda Count
Placement | Animal | Points |
1 | Chukar | 17 |
T-2 | Bass | 12 |
T-2 | Sturgeon | 12 |
4 | Trout | 11 |
5 | Salmon | 8 |
Table 3: Results Using Coombs Method
Placement | Animal |
1 | Chukar |
T-2 | Trout |
T-2 | Bass |
4 | Sturgeon |
5 | Salmon |
Table 4: Results Using Hare System
Placement | Animal |
1 | Chukar |
T-2 | Salmon |
T-2 | Sturgeon |
T-4 | Bass |
T-4 | Trout |
From all these systems, Chukar was the winner. However, I wanted to see if Chukar is in fact a Condorcet Winner, and Table 5 shows that it is. In a head-to-head matchup, Chukar still beats all of the other options.
Table 5: Condorcet Matchup
Matchup | Result | Winner |
Chukar vs. Salmon | 3-1 | Chukar |
Chukar vs. Sturgeon | 3-1 | Chukar |
Chukar vs. Bass | 3-1 | Chukar |
Chukar vs. Trout | 4-0 | Chukar |
The most interesting part of this is not which animal ended up winning. There was no difference between the methods there. However, it is notable the differences in the order. Most notable is that Salmon came in last in both the Borda Count and the Coombs Method yet secured second place in the Hare System. It demonstrates that the Hare System eliminated the option neither loved nor hated first, while Coombs and Borda got rid of the option most people enjoyed the least.
No comments:
Post a Comment