Stigler's work tells us that regulation is the friend of the incumbent, and this could not be exemplified better than by Local Law 18 in New York City, passed in early 2022. Rising concerns about housing affordability lead policy makers to consider enforcing a much older law requiring short term rentals under 30 days to register with the city, of which only about 200 were permitted. If they were permitted, the host had to be in the apartment for the duration of the stay --- a de facto ban on Airbnb in NYC. Unsurprisingly, this was not a bill of pure intention -- the hotel lobby spent millions, 20 times more than Airbnb, on getting this regulation passed, surely not for the virtue of rent decreases.
Post-regulation, the lobbying investment paid back dividends. Revenue in the industry increased by about $2.5 billion due to this regulation, and daily prices went up by about $17 a night without any meaningful change in cost. Regulation was captured well.
What's worse is that the rent failed to decline. It seems that a regulation of Airbnb's either forced them into illegal activity, or the supply of housing is so large that the apartments converted from short term rentals to actual homes was a mere drop in the bucket. Policy makers professed good intentions, yet they raised prices for consumers and handed barrels of cash to the hotel industry.
No comments:
Post a Comment